Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Supported by

Bayesian Probability in Taxi Cab and Girl Wearing Trousers problem?

Hello everyone,
this is not strictly relevant to JASP but I have a question about two problems which aim to explain Bayesian probability to learners. I really hope someone can help me understand this better.

In Eirini Koutoumanou's UCL workshop, a problem is given whereby a student from a school is observed as wearing trousers. Eirini's workbook gives Pr(θ|data)=Pr(data|θ)Pr(θ) / Pr(data) as Bayes' Theorem. Because only 40% of students are girls, and half the girls wear trousers (50%), and all the boys wear trousers (60%) this gives us: Pr(observed student who wore trousers was a girl)=Pr(any student is girl) *Pr(any girl wears trousers) / Pr(any student wearing trousers) = 04.0.5/0.8=0.25.

In the taxi cab problem (Tversky & Kahnemann, 1982), 15% of all cabs in a city are blue, 85% are green. An accident happens where an eyewitness claims that the cab was blue. When tested for his/her eyesight, the witness correctly identifies a blue cab as blue 80% of the time and wrongly as green 20% of the time. They give a different formula for calculating the Bayesian probability: Pr(blue cab) / Pr (green cab) * Pr (eyewitness correct) / Pr (eyewitness wrong), which gives them a probability of 0.41.

However, if you switch the formulae between the problems, you get different results:
Taxi formula with Girl data: Pr(student is girl) / Pr (student is boy) * Pr (girl wears trousers) / (student wears trousers) = 0.41.
Girl formula with taxi data: Pr(cab is blue)Pr(eyewitness correct)/Pr(eyewitness correct and cab is blue)= 0.150.8/0.12=1.

Where have I gone wrong here?

Comments

  • The Tversky & Kahneman formulation expresses the odds, not the probability. If you write that equation out in full (including the = sign) you will see that the posterior odds is 0.7058824. To get to the associated posterior probability you need to go 0.7058824/1.7058824 = .41.

    For instance, in the Taxi formula with the Girl data you have:
    Pr(student is girl) / Pr (student is boy) * Pr (girl wears trousers) / (student wears trousers)
    but the last term should be "boy wears trousers", not "student wears trousers"

    E.J.

Sign In or Register to comment.