Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Supported by

Potentially daft question about data accumulation


I just wanted to canvass opinion here of people who know much more than me on 2 related issues.

Issue 1

Say we have 2 datasets both with the same treatment and control in. We could analyse in 2 ways:

  • Perform our test on Dataset 1, with a default 0.707 prior. Use the posterior as the prior to perform the test on dataset 2


  • Put all the data together and perform the test with the 0.707 prior.

Are these two equivalent, are they very close or coudl they feasibly be very differnt?

Issue 2

What are the board's thoughts on using Bayesian for exploratory analysis and using the data from which the hypotheses were generated in a more confirmatory analysis, after collecting more data? My opinion is, as long as you are open about how many exploratory outcomes you tested (the more tested the more likely findings are spurious) and as long as you collect a decent chunk of data in a more confirmatory study (Maybe 2-4 times the amount as in an exploratory study) this should be fine. In other words, as long as you are open about what you did, and the evidence can be judged accordingly. Obviously, if you look at 10,000 outcomes, and only add 2x the data in the hypothesis generating group, your results are not going to be very credible.

Specifically, in some data collected for an MA we explored 8 possibly models. We found anecdotal evidence for an effect in (n=51) participants. We collected another n=79, to probe this outcome further, and we find extreme evidence for this effect. I tend to believe that the effect is not spurious based on that evidence.




  • Hi Gareth,

    1. Yes, these are equivalent
    2. My own preference is to keep the exploratory and confirmatory stage separate. So I would encourage exploratory analyses, but the confirmatory stage should feature new data, and not contain old data that inspired the hypothesis that you seek to test. There is some Bayesian debate about this, however (I'm writing a series of chapters and posts about this).



  • edited April 2019


    Oh that is Brilliant! It is nice to get a second oppinion. (I was beiang a bit lazy with the first question)

    Regrding Issue 2. I am also writing a paper about this at the moment. I'll add in my perspective as I think it might be interesting.

    So I am a medical statistician by trade but I used to be a quantitative linguist. The paper I am writing is for a lingusitics journal. I do not think that you should explore and comfirm (unplanned) on the same data in med stats, I do think that it is "fine", not ideal, but "fine" in Linguistics. I will explain why I think this.

    Med stats is really well funded and it is possiblee to get as much data as you need, also the consequenses of getting things wrong can be really serious. Linguistics is really poorly funded, outside a few key areas, the consequenses of getting somethign wrong are not quite as serious. Most of the data that is currently collecetd inlingustics is on small datasets by individual researchers and, although many lingusits don't know it, has very little right to be called comfirmitory. There is a movement towards the pre-registration of studies in linguistics at the moment, which I think is great, but I do think that that might stifle small scale exploratory resaerch somewhat. That is why I'm suggesting a Bayesian framework for upgrading Exploratory to more comfirmitory outcomes in lingusitics research. Ideally, you woudl do a new study from scratch, but that is often not possible becasue of lack of funding in lingusitics. I think that a "Bayesian upgrade" is a good half way house that is achievable for smaller-scale researchers to have some claim to having produces comfirmitory results. Not allowing them to add the data on which the hypotheses were generated limits the ammount of this kind of work that will ever see the light of day.

    In summary, I think you need to make a judgement call on the consequences of making a wrong inference and weigh that up against the narrowing of reasearch focus that requiring a completely new dataset woudl bring.

    Anyway, that is my rather pragmatic perspective on it. I also see your point too and would 100% agree in an ideal world.


Sign In or Register to comment.

agen judi bola , sportbook, casino, togel, number game, singapore, tangkas, basket, slot, poker, dominoqq, agen bola. Semua permainan bisa dimainkan hanya dengan 1 ID. minimal deposit 50.000 ,- bonus cashback hingga 10% , diskon togel hingga 66% bisa bermain di android dan IOS kapanpun dan dimana pun. poker , bandarq , aduq, domino qq , dominobet. Semua permainan bisa dimainkan hanya dengan 1 ID. minimal deposit 10.000 ,- bonus turnover 0.5% dan bonus referral 20%. Bonus - bonus yang dihadirkan bisa terbilang cukup tinggi dan memuaskan, anda hanya perlu memasang pada situs yang memberikan bursa pasaran terbaik yaitu Bola168. Situs penyedia segala jenis permainan poker online kini semakin banyak ditemukan di Internet, salah satunya TahunQQ merupakan situs Agen Judi Domino66 Dan BandarQ Terpercaya yang mampu memberikan banyak provit bagi bettornya. Permainan Yang Di Sediakan Dewi365 Juga sangat banyak Dan menarik dan Peluang untuk memenangkan Taruhan Judi online ini juga sangat mudah . Mainkan Segera Taruhan Sportbook anda bersama Agen Judi Bola Bersama Dewi365 Kemenangan Anda Berapa pun akan Terbayarkan. Tersedia 9 macam permainan seru yang bisa kamu mainkan hanya di dalam 1 ID saja. Permainan seru yang tersedia seperti Poker, Domino QQ Dan juga BandarQ Online. Semuanya tersedia lengkap hanya di ABGQQ. Situs ABGQQ sangat mudah dimenangkan, kamu juga akan mendapatkan mega bonus dan setiap pemain berhak mendapatkan cashback mingguan. ABGQQ juga telah diakui sebagai Bandar Domino Online yang menjamin sistem FAIR PLAY disetiap permainan yang bisa dimainkan dengan deposit minimal hanya Rp.25.000. DEWI365 adalah Bandar Judi Bola Terpercaya & resmi dan terpercaya di indonesia. Situs judi bola ini menyediakan fasilitas bagi anda untuk dapat bermain memainkan permainan judi bola. Didalam situs ini memiliki berbagai permainan taruhan bola terlengkap seperti Sbobet, yang membuat DEWI365 menjadi situs judi bola terbaik dan terpercaya di Indonesia. Tentunya sebagai situs yang bertugas sebagai Bandar Poker Online pastinya akan berusaha untuk menjaga semua informasi dan keamanan yang terdapat di POKERQQ13. Kotakqq adalah situs Judi Poker Online Terpercayayang menyediakan 9 jenis permainan sakong online, dominoqq, domino99, bandarq, bandar ceme, aduq, poker online, bandar poker, balak66, perang baccarat, dan capsa susun. Dengan minimal deposit withdraw 15.000 Anda sudah bisa memainkan semua permaina pkv games di situs kami. Jackpot besar,Win rate tinggi, Fair play, PKV Games