Bayes factor (inclusion BF) contradicts p value
I'm running Repeated Measures ANOVAs on this data file: https://osf.io/3gynm/ (results_aggregated_exp2_index_vs_thumb.txt)
I include the factors "Type" (probe vs. irrelevant) and "Hand-position" (index vs. thumb), for the "duration RT mean" variable: "duration_RT_mean_probe_0", "duration_RT_mean_irrelevant_0", "duration_RT_mean_probe_1", "duration_RT_mean_irrelevant_1" (where _0 is index and _1 is thumb). See:
And what's weird is that for the interaction I find a p = .004:
But a BF = 0.182 (inclusion BF based on matched model - when based on all models, it's even 0.077):
So p value supports difference quite strongly (.004), and BF supports equivalence substantially (1 / 0.182 = 5.495). (There is a similar contradiction for the Type main effect too, but there at least the p value is not so clear.)
Any ideas what to make of this? Perhaps any references about interpreting such a case?