[solved] Sketchpad and Canvas question

Comments

• sebastiaan

  October 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Hi Ricky,

  Assuming that you indeed have a sketchpad item named engage_disengage in your experiment, the problem is likely because the canvas of engage_disengage hasn't been prepared yet at the moment that you call the copy_sketchpad() function.

  More specifically, if you were to place this code in the prepare phase before the engage_disengage sketchpad, then you will get this error message, because you are trying to copy a canvas that hasn't been constructed yet. If you place this code in the run phase or after the sketchpad, then you should be fine.

  For more information about the prepare-run strategy, see:

  • http://osdoc.cogsci.nl/usage/prepare-run/

  Cheers!
  Sebastiaan

  
  
  Check out SigmundAI.eu for our OpenSesame AI assistant!
  
• rmacatee

  October 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Hey Sebastian,

  Thanks, I actually had the sketchpad in the unused items section because I was trying to load it exclusively from inline script code because I was worried about lag time in loading the sketchpad after a certain trigger had been hit in inline code the step before in the sequence, but reading over that it looks like load time is pretty negligible given that the sketchpad is prepared beforehand..

  Anways, thanks!

  -Ricky
• LeeB_86

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Hello again,

  I'm having a similar issue to the one above (hence resurrecting the post), I'm trying to copy a sketchpad item ('stripes') into an inline script item ('ongoing-script') which already contains a canvas ('trial_display').

  I need the sketchpad to overlay the canvas whilst still showing the canvas item beneath - basically so that the lines on the sketchpad disrupt the lines on the 'trial_display' canvas.

  I'm just having a little trouble copying the canvas - specifically what to write where in the script entry...

  Any pointers would be great!

  Thanks,

  Lee
• sebastiaan

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Hi Lee,

  A canvas object is not transparent, so you cannot combine the content of two canvas objects. What you can do, is first copy the canvas from a sketchpad and then draw extra things on it, like so:

  my_canvas = self.copy_sketchpad('sketchpad1')
  my_canvas.fixdot()
  my_canvas.show()
  

  But the reverse is not possible, i.e. you cannot first draw things onto a canvas and then add the contents of another canvas. So my recommendation would be to restructure the code so that you don't need to superimpose two canvas objects, which is usually possible.

  Otherwise, in principle it is possible to 'hack' your code together by delving into the OpenSesame internals. For example, for the psycho back-end, every canvas has a stim_list, which you can copy and combine with the stim_list from another canvas. This is a back-end-specific hack though, I wouldn't do it unless it's really necessary.

  from openexp.canvas import canvas
  # Copy canvas objects from two sketchpads
  my_canvas1 = self.copy_sketchpad('sketchpad1')
  my_canvas2 = self.copy_sketchpad('sketchpad2')
  # Create a new empty canvas
  my_canvas3 = canvas(exp)
  # And copy all stimuli from the other canvas objects, except for the
  # first stimulus of my_canvas2, which is a background rectangle.
  # This will only work for the psycho backend!
  my_canvas3.stim_list = my_canvas1.stim_list + my_canvas2.stim_list[1:]
  my_canvas3.show()
  

  Cheers!
  Sebastiaan

  
  
  Check out SigmundAI.eu for our OpenSesame AI assistant!
  
• LeeB_86

  November 2013 edited November 2013

  Hmmm, this is actually related to a previous problem (http://forum.cogsci.nl/index.php?p=/discussion/619/solved-changing-polygon-linestyle#Item_5), but so far I haven't been able to create the workaround you suggested and make it work the way I need.

  The canvas 'trial_display' shows all of the primary stimuli, the 'stripes' will be a secondary stimulus (i.e. "press key X when the primary image is disrupted" so they only need to occur twice in each of the last two sessions.

  I had thought to just copy the sketchpad stripes and present it over the top of the trial_display canvas, but all I get is the 'stripes screen' wedged between two presentations of the primary stimuli... I have also tried this as a solution http://www.cogsci.nl/forum/index.php?p=/discussion/156/open-question-on-how-to-make-a-sketchpad-object-partly-transparent/p1, but in reverse, however I can't make it work either.

  I have decided to post the script via pastebin as a last resort (I have started collecting data on the first condition for this experiment, so time has become a factor in making this work... I am now a desperate chap!)

  Pastebin here

  Hopefully you can see the problem, I need to show the sketchpad on top of the canvas [trial_display] whilst still being able to see the stimuli beneath... thus the image pairs will have 'broken lines' as you previously suggested.

  Many thanks!

  Lee
• sebastiaan

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Hi Lee,

  You are first showing trial_display and then stripes. As I explained above, this will not cause the contents of both canvas objects to be combined, but will first cause (only) trial_display to be shown, followed by (only) stripes.

  In your case, it's probably easiest to draw the white vertical stripes on your trial_display with something like the following script:

  # Draw vertical stripes
  trial_display.set_penwidth(50)
  for x in range(0, 2*trial_display.xcenter(), 100):
      trial_display.line(x, 0, x, trial_display.ycenter()*2, color='white')
  

  That way you don't have to bother with copying a sketchpad, etc. Does that make sense?

  As an aside, you have put all your code in the prepare phase of your inline_script items. Although this may work, it is good style to use the prepare phase only for preparatory stuff, and not for stimulus presentation, etc. See also:

  • http://osdoc.cogsci.nl/usage/prepare-run/

  Cheers!
  Sebastiaan

  
  
  Check out SigmundAI.eu for our OpenSesame AI assistant!
  
• LeeB_86

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Sebastiaan,

  That looks similar to a Bresenham algorithm (I think!) which I saw somewhere in my trying-to-find-a-solution research. I'll give it a try and let you know what happens.

  As for the prepare-run, I presume then that if I move all of my stimulus presentation to the run phase it will reduce any timing lag I'm experiencing?

  Best,

  Lee
• sebastiaan

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  As for the prepare-run, I presume then that if I move all of my stimulus presentation to the run phase it will reduce any timing lag I'm experiencing?

  Not necessarily, but it will avoid problems when you combine your inline scripts with other items that do follow the prepare-run strategy.

  
  
  Check out SigmundAI.eu for our OpenSesame AI assistant!
  
• LeeB_86

  November 2013 edited November 2013

  I've incorporated the script snippet into my experiment as:

  # Draw vertical stripes
  trial_display.set_penwidth(10)
  for x in range(64, 2*trial_display.xcenter(), 30):
      trial_display.line(x, 256, x, 512, color='white')
  

  This covers the area I require.

  I've taken a picture - its not great, but you can see vertical grey lines between each white stripe. This isn't ideal as it adds 'accidental stimuli' to the screen, rendering any responses ambiguous... Just wondering if there is anything that can be done about this as I haven't a clue (aside from changing the instructions to "press key X when image is disrupted").

  

  It also causes a huge pause just before it is shown which is a massive clue to the participant that something is going to happen and also messes up the timing. I've tried putting it in both the prepare and run phases - seems to work better in the run phase.

  Hopefully this will be the last issue I have - it's the LAST stimulus... so frustrating!

  Thanks,

  Lee

  P.S. I also put all of my display code in the run phase as suggested - much neater!
• sebastiaan

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  Yes, I see them. I suspect that these gray lines result from the way that Expyriment (and PsychoPy for that matter) draws the stimuli, using OpenGL. This sometimes causes a bit of fuzziness, which in this case appears to be especially bothersome. I don't know if there's anything that can be done about it really, except disabling OpenGL under the back-end preferences or switching to the legacy back-end.

  Given these gray lines and the speed issue, perhaps you would be better off using a semitransparent image as a mask. For example, you could create an image that is the size of your stimuli and is transparent except for some white vertical stripes. Then you could draw this image (mask.png) on top of your stimuli, instead of drawing the masking lines one-by-one as I suggested previously:

  trial_display.image(exp.get_file('mask.png'))
  

  And to make sure that the timing is identical between mask and non-mask trials, you could show a completely transparent image as a dummy mask on non-mask trials. Is that an idea?

  Cheers!
  Sebastiaan

  
  
  Check out SigmundAI.eu for our OpenSesame AI assistant!
  
• LeeB_86

  November 2013 edited 3:56AM

  I used Paint.Net to make the stripe.png files (a different version for different sessions - I don't need participants practicing now...) and it works like a charm.

  Very many thanks, that has made me a happy chap!

  Best,

  Lee