EJ
About
- Username
- EJ
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,642
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member, Administrator, Moderator
Comments
-
Do your columns start with a variable name? E.J.
-
Hi Perseus You won't get the BF10 from JASP. The BF10 from JASP is based on a specific set of priors; the implicit BF10 from the BIC is based on a different set of priors! Cheers, E.J.
-
Hi Perseus, Yes, BIC is an approximation to the Bayes factor, and you can use the transformations shown in the blog to make that more clear. But there is no "single" Bayes factor -- the JZS approach can be viewed as just a somewhat more i…
-
Hi Perseus, The Bayesian ANOVA is not computed from the classical ANOVA. Instead, the Bayesian ANOVA is obtained by applying the "Jeffreys Zellner Siow" framework developed in regression and the t-test to the case of ANOVA. An introductor…
-
Hi Francesco, It is always a good idea to use Bayesian inference. But at the very least you can argue that the two paradigms are complementary, and it is counterproductive to ignore the Bayesian outcomes. So my advice is to heed the editor's advice…
-
Right now the go-to paper is this one (Rouder & Morey: Default Bayes Factors for Model Selection in Regression): http://pcl.missouri.edu/sites/default/files/p_1.pdf Cheers, E.J.
-
Hi Hanna, This is a great question. Some brief thoughts: 1. With BFs in between 1 and 3 you have not learned much with respect to the specific model-comparison question you were studying. with N=75, the posterior distribution will be relatively pea…
-
Hi Vince, Ah that's too bad. I'm not sure how to proceed -- the JASP website lists the OS levels required. You could try running a windows emulator and installing JASP there. Not sure whether this will work -- if you have it working please let me k…
-
Hi Andrew, This issue came up before I think. Let me pass this on to the JASP team member responsible for the nonparametric tests. Cheers, E.J.
-
This test is not implemented in JASP or BayesFactor yet. There is some work on hypothesis testing in Bayesian GLMMs, but I'm not sure it is in a stage where it is implemented in a convenient software package. E.J.
-
Hi Francesco, Completely correct! E.J.
-
Hi Glenn, I'll forward this to the team member responsible for the classical ANOVA. I recall there was a discussion, but perhaps I misremember. E.J.
-
Yes, that's the one. The go-to reference is the Jamil paper (open access, but here's the sci-hub link anyway: http://sci-hub.cc/10.3758/s13428-016-0739-8) E.J.
-
Hi Eduard, This is really a question for Richard, who is in charge of the "BayesFactor" component of this Forum. I'll specifically attend him to your question. Cheers, E.J.
-
Hi Peter, "Given that the summary stats module can also handle F-statistics from ANOVA analyses" -- Can it? " the ANOVA option in the summary stats module" -- but there isn't one. Regardless, if you have the t-statistic, there i…
-
I don't think it's a problem at all. Did you see this paper by Etz and Lakens about not every study needing to provide picture-perfect results? Besides, I think you should only be applauded for being transparent. And my guess is that this will happe…
-
Hi Eduard, I'm not sure what tests would be most effected by a violation of assumptions. It feels a little like comparing apples and oranges, but perhaps it can be done. Yes I meant that blog post -- or the next one, http://bayesfactor.blogspot.nl/2…
-
Hi Eduard, I assume the interest is in the interaction? In general BFs are less enthusiastic because they look at both sides of the coin --H0 and H1-- instead of just focusing on H0. Indeed, multiplying BFs is not allowed, as it uses the prior agai…
-
Hi Paul, This sounds like a fantastic data set. In, say, Bayesian ANOVA it is not an issue if you have more participants in condition A than in condition B, but when we take the mean of the participants then it is an issue that some means are based…
-
7e-8 is a really small number! E.J.
-
The reason for in the increased support in the inclusion method may be due to the fact that some models (like the null model, or the model with only one factor) perform very poorly. I am not so sure that this effect is of interest to you. Cheers E.J.
-
Hi Markus, When you have few models, I am in favor of including the entire tables, perhaps as a supplement. Cheers, E.J.
-
I was a bit caught up and did not respond too quickly. I have now responded to a similar question you just asked. Sorry about my tardiness. I try to answer quickly but sometimes diapers and deadlines get in the way. Cheers, E.J.
-
Hi Markus, Well, I would just be transparent. Sometimes you do get these conflicts and, in my opinion, they urge caution. If you had a specific contrast in mind then you ought to test that (I believe Richard has a blog post showing how this can be …
-
Hi Markus, In JASP we use the marginality principle, which means that when an interaction is present, so are the constituent main effects. The most straightforward test is to compare the full model against the model with only the main effects. When…
-
Hi Sau-Chin, If you want to test whether the effect increases, I think I'd suggest a linear contrast or perhaps just an ordinal constraint. I think Richard once wrote a blogpost on how to do that with the BayesFactor R package. Basically you take th…
-
Yes, the default settings are meant to serve as an "objective" specification that can be used across a wide range of different scenarios. Cheers, E.J.
-
Hi Pieter, With respect to assigning probability to a spike: I don't have an issue with it, for the following reasons: 1. What the BF assesses is not whether H0 is true. The BF compares the predictive performance of two models (H0 and H1 here). Bot…
-
Hi Markus, Some analyses require a numerical approximation. The quality of the approximation is indicated in the output tables as a "%error". If I'm not mistaken the current version of JASP allows you to improve the quality of the approxi…
-
I'm not sure, we'll have to ask Richard. I'll forward this to him. E.J.